Happily Getting A Tax Refund

I’ve had a long and bumpy road when it comes to taxes. I officially became part of the working world when I turned 13, and was old enough to get a work permit. Honestly, I don’t remember anything about taxes as a teenager; I’m sure my annual returns were filed as part of my parents’. I went to college in another state, where I worked a variety of jobs to help support myself. That state had a reciprocal agreement with my home state, which meant state taxes weren’t withheld. Every year, I was writing a check to the government. I didn’t have a career plan out of college, so I ended up working at a restaurant while I figured things out. I did pretty well in tips, so my hourly wage of $2.35 didn’t put a dent in my tax liability. I was still writing a check to Uncle Sam every year.

You can imagine how happy I was when I finally started getting money back from the government. State refunds are dicey; Some years I owe, some years I get something back. But now days it’s usually not more than $100 either way. This year I’m getting back $81 on my state refund. Woot woot! But the federal refunds are the really exciting part! Unfortunately, my mortgage has never been enough to deduct the mortgage interest; You have to be able to itemize, and I’ve never had enough deductions to beat the standard deduction. But I was able to take educational credits some years. I don’t think my refund was ever more than $3,000. I usually expect around $1,500. This year I’m clocking in at $1,669.

I’ve heard the mantra a million times in regards to refunds: Don’t give the government a free loan! If you’re getting a refund, adjust your withholding! Keep your money all year long! I get what they’re saying. I’m still not gonna do it. Why? One reason is I’d rather get money back than owe. It’s such a fine line there, I’d rather err on the side of getting a refund. I’ve never heard of anyone breaking even at tax time.

I also don’t buy the whole reasoning that it’s detrimental to me to not have that money all year long. My federal refund of $1,669 comes out to $32 per week on my check. Sure, that money could have been making a dent in my debt. But, more than likely, at least some of that money would have slipped through the cracks. It’s much easier to piddle away $32 than it is $1,669. Every penny of that $1,669 is going toward my student loan. I couldn’t have said that for sure if I’d gotten it a week at a time.

But what about the interest? Okay, let’s consider that. I pay 3.88% interest on my student loan. Assuming I would have used all of that extra $32 per week to make an extra payment each month, I would have saved myself right around $30 in interest in 2014 on my student loan. Hey, $30 is nothing to sneeze at. But if even one of those weekly amounts hadn’t made it into a student loan payment, that $30 interest savings would have been a wash. And let’s face it, I managed to find all kinds of priorities other than my student loans last year.

We all have our own “tricks” that help us save money. Right now, getting a tax refund every year works for me. It’s a big push towards making my goal. And getting a big start at the beginning of the year really gives me motivation to keep rolling. To me, it’s worth it to get the tax refund. If I was getting more money back each year, I’d definitely reconsider my withholding amounts. But I don’t feel like $1,669 is out of bounds.

Are you getting a tax refund? What’s your take on the refund debate in personal finance?

– Cindy W.


  1. I view the refund as a savings account. I have a nasty tendency to spend extra money that’s lying around that didn’t go straight to savings.

    That said, I’ve been writing a check to uncle sam for the last four years…

    1. I always hated having to write the government a check!

      With interest rates on savings being as low as they are, it isn’t much different! I earned around $15 last year on my savings account, for an amount much higher than my refund!

  2. I’m actually considering adjusting my withholding allowances so I get more of a refund. I like the forced-savings idea! I also like getting a big check; I can’t wait for my refund this year — all $1000 of it — which is more than I’ve had in ages! I don’t know how people manage to get so much back every year, I never seem to. Anyway, I think making that student loan payment will be super fun.

    1. Yeah, I’m definitely looking forward to that student loan payment this month!

      I’m a “Single – 0”, which typically gets me a refund around $1,500. When I was taking classes towards my MSA it was even better, with all the educational credits. I do agree it’s nice having a chunk of money coming to you every year. And, unlike so many other forms of savings, it never “crosses your hands” during the year, so you don’t even miss it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *